When my oldest son was turning four, I convinced him to have
a pirate-themed party, mainly because I needed a yard of topsoil for our flower
beds. Well, that’s why I wanted the party. He just loved the idea of digging
for buried treasures. In fact, this party was such a hit that several years
later, we did it again for our next son when he was turning five though we
really didn’t need any topsoil!
For both parties, I had the topsoil delivered to our
driveway that morning. With the help of my best friend, we buried Mardi Gras beads, fake gold coins, plastic
gemstones, and other assorted pirate treasures all within the huge mound of
earth. We then set out to hide the treasure
map in the backyard. I had made it the night before with a large strip of
brown packing paper I already had since I had been busy selling stuff on Ebay
at the time. I carefully burned the edges with a candle to make it authentic
looking.
To make the cake, I baked a yellow cake mix in my
largest bread loaf pan. I then carefully cut the top ¼ off and dirty iced
the whole thing with butter cream icing.
(Dirty iced means icing it lightly with frosting without concerns for crumbs
mixing in. You can do it and put the cake in the freezer. Then when you ice the
cake carefully, you won’t have to worry about getting crumbs in your icing.) I
had bought as much fake jewelry candy as I could find like ring pops, Smarties, Gobstoppers, Jolly Ranchers, and sugar necklaces, and I added Fruit Gushers to look like rhinestones.
I set them all between the top and bottom pieces so it looked like they were
flowing out of a partially closed chest. To create the handles and leather
straps on the treasure chest, I used red Fruit
by the Foot or Fruit Roll-Ups.

The first party, I made one large cake; the second year, I
made two. First, let me explain how I got away with one cake for the first
party. Besides baking a yellow cake for the treasure chest, I baked a chocolate cake using a 9x13 pan and
iced it with butter cream icing. I
had previously smashed up a package of graham crackers, so right after I iced
this cake, I sprinkled the graham cracker crumbs all over it to look like sand.
Then I set the treasure chest cake on top.

For the second party, I decided to make a pirate’s hat cake
along with the treasure chest. To do this, I baked a chocolate cake in two 9 inch round cake pans. Once cooled, I
stacked the two cakes and iced in between them so they’d stick together. Next,
I cut the two circles in half. I then cut one of the half-circles in half
again, so I had a total of two half-circles and four quarter-circles. I propped
up the half-circles on their side and iced them with chocolate icing. I then put the quarter-circles on either side,
facing out and iced them as well. To finish off the pirate hat, I used some
white icing in a tube with a fie tip to draw my skull and crossbones and
outline the hat. We also served bowls of Goldfish crackers as a snack since pirates must eat lots of fish while at sea!
Both parties were structured the same way, and here’s what
we did. As the guests arrived, they were turned into pirates. I applied a
pirate tattoo and gave them each an eye patch and pirate hat to wear. Once
everyone was ready, I read a children’s book titled How I Became a Pirate to
get them thinking and acting like pirates, not that a bunch of preschoolers
really need any help. I then informed them that I had a feeling there was a
buried treasure close by and suggested they all search the backyard for a
treasure map. So, with toy shovels and empty goody bags in hand, a dozen tiny
pirates scoured my backyard for several minutes in search of a treasure map.
When it was discovered, we held it up and showed them how we needed to follow
it to find the X that must mark the spot, so through the backyard,
around the house, and across the front yard we marched until we spotted the mound of dirt.
Boys love dirt! For the next fifteen minutes, they dug all through that stuff,
filling their bags with pirate-themed trinkets like plastic
rings and tiny telescopes.
Afterward, we cleaned up our pirates and brought them in to
have the cake and open presents. Thanks to hardwood floors, I wasn’t worried
about them tracking in the dirt, but if you have carpet, you may want to have
this party held entirely outdoors. We had guests ranging in age from two to
nine at both parties, and all of them enjoyed the treasure hunt.

If you need to landscape your lawn, consider having a pirate
party for your child, so at least the expense of the topsoil will also serve as
entertainment for your birthday guests!